|
A Contextual Paraphrase of I Corinthians 11:2-16
By Bruce Norquist Ph.D.
From chapters 11 through 14 Paul responds to questions that
the Corinthians have asked him concerning propriety in worship. He begins this
section (11:2-16) by speaking of a first century fashion phenomena of church
members who were adopting hairstyles (long hair let down) that clearly reflected
the manner and custom of effeminate homosexual men and loose living women. As
far as we can tell, Paul has never brought up this particular matter with them
before. Much of what he has to say is time bound but the principles are timeless.
What follows is a contextual paraphrase of I Corinthians 11:2-16 in the light
of recent scholarship. While he should not be blamed for any of my mistakes
see, for example, Philip B. Payne’s article: "Wild Hair and Gender
Equality in 1 Cor 11:2-16." Priscilla Papers 20 number 3 (2006) 9-18.
2. I commend you for upholding the customs and traditions I have taught you.
I am glad that you are showing me respect in this way. Now (can we talk?) about
a custom that I am not pleased with. (It has to do with certain fashions you
have embraced that are not matters of moral indifference. In this particular
instance, something as simple as how you wear your hair can tend to blur the
natural and appropriate distinctions that exist between men and women.) How
should I begin? 3. Foundational to everything that I have to say is the idea
that the source of every man is Christ, and the source of every woman is man,
and the source of Christ is God. 4. Every man who prays or prophesies with long
effeminately styled hair dishonors God as the source of his masculinity. 5.
Correspondingly, every woman who prays or prophesies with her hair - not done
up in a respectable fashion - (but hanging down loose in the seductive manner
of an immoral woman) is showing disrespect for her ultimate source – God.
It’s disgraceful. 6. What I am saying is that, if a woman wears her hair
down in public, she may as well have her head shaved (like a convicted sex criminal!).
Clearly, no Christian woman should adopt a hairstyle that evokes this image.
7. Similarly, a man should not assume the coiffure of a girlie-man who wears
his hair like a woman. Humanity as a whole has, after all, been created in the
image of God - as male and female. It is in glorying in our created order as
men and women that we are fulfilled and God is glorified. 8. (This is not something
new; it has been established as a cherished ideal from the beginning.) What
does the Scripture say? Man did not come from woman - but woman from man; 9.
neither was man created for woman but woman for man. 10. It is for this reason
(not to mention the holy angels – who wing their way above us as we worship)
that a woman ought to signify the power she has to fulfill God’s design*
by following the respectable practice of doing her hair up properly in public
and not letting it down in a way that makes her look like a sex object. 11.
(And by the way, guys, don’t read too much into this notion of man’s
priority in the creation account; I quoted the Genesis account as an illustration
of the mutual role that the sexes play in reflecting the glory of God as male
AND female.) Look at it this way: IN THE LORD a new order has been established;
from now on, woman is not to be considered separate from man - nor is man to
be considered separate from woman. 12. For as woman came from man, so also man
comes from woman. But don’t forget the big picture; everything comes from
God. 13. This begs the question: is it appropriate for a woman to pray in public
with her hair styled in a way that exchanges the image of God (so beautifully
reflected in her chaste femininity) for the look of a promiscuous woman? 14.
Similarly, does not the very order of creation teach you that it is degrading
for a man wear his hair in an effeminate manner? 15. Don’t get me wrong,
a woman’s long hair, if it is done up properly, is a beautiful thing.
It has been given to her to as a covering to distinguish her as a woman. 16.
If anyone wants to be contentious about this, simply tell them that we have
no custom that says (as some of you evidently do) that “Anything goes
in worship”. Show some respect for God (and each other) by deporting yourself
with propriety in public.
* Often translated: “wear as a symbol of her subjection”
– whereas in the Greek it means “a sign of her authority”.
|